And Now by carocali
He threw the knife to floor and tried to get up, looking for another more painful option.
Broken by leighannwallace
Dean hangs up on Sam after telling him they're safer apart. Lucifer decides to step in for a little 'counseling'.
Chaser by psiChic
'What're you doing out here?' Dean tried to keep his voice casual. His eyes darted from the empty bottles to the piece in Sam's unsteady hands. Sam flinched at the sound of Dean's voice. It took a moment for him to reply. 'Nothin'.' 'Nothin', huh? With an empty six pack and a loaded gun?'
destruction by sylvanelfqueen (also here)
Sam doesn't think twice before stepping in the street and into the path of a speeding SUV.
Fell on Black Days by snarkymuch (also here)
You can only take so much before you break. Since Dean returned from purgatory, Sam has been taking hits. This was one hit too many. S8.
Fractured Fairytale by dean_and_sammy
Set after Dean told Sam to pick a hemisphere and hung up on him in S5. Sam realizes that he has to stop Lucifer from taking him for a vessel. At all costs.
Giving Up Is Hard To Do by authoressnebula
'I'd hoped to see you again, before...but. I kinda figured it wasn't ever going to happen. You needed me gone, and I understand. Bobby said you were doing okay with Castiel, and I'm glad. He'll make a good partner.'
Hitchiker by skagtrendy1 (also here)
No one wanted to trade Sam's worthless soul for John's. But there was something else he could do for Dean. Sam's trembling fingers closed around the bottle of pills.
Hush Little Brother by Chloe Winchester
Sam only knows one way to stop Lucifer from possessing him.
I'll Fix This For You by iamtryN
Silence equaled confirmation to Sam that he was both Dean's baggage and his burden. 'It's better this way. Let me go… you need them.'
Incidentally by veronamay
If he'd been watching Sam more closely, he would've seen the signs.
In the Twilight by Darktales (also here)
Devils Trap Tag. The night before Dean is getting released from the hospital, Sam realizes there is only way he can protect his brother.
Losing It by RainbowBetty (also here)
Tag to 5.1, Sympathy for the Devil. Bobby's words cut deep, but worse by far was his brother's silence.
My Sacrifice by siyafa (also here)
Sam's guilt finally catches up with him and he does something drastic. Dean is left to pick up the pieces.
Never Going to be Okay by LaurenEP18
'What the hell is wrong with me? Am I so weak that I can't even tell my own brother that I needed him to stay with me? That I may need protection from myself, not the supernatural creatures that go bump in the night?'
sequel:Keeping Up The Facade
'You- You're the best big brother. I mean, don't f-feel guilty.'
Nothing is Guaranteed by NC Girl
'What, Sam? What in God's name did you see that was so' 'I saw a way out, okay? I saw a way to take the
burden off of you.'
Of Obligations and Desperation by skag trendy
Following a confrontation with a despair demon, a fight between the brothers sends Sam over the edge. Set Season 2 after Croatoan.
Oh Brother, Where Art Thou? by kelhome
Dean's heart had kicked up. 'Back up. You 'tested it out?' What the hell does that mean?' Sam shrugged. 'Sliced my wrists in the bathroom. Woke up the next morning, good as new.
Anyway, what do you think of the salt and burn thing. Might work, right?'
One Shot by authoressnebula
One shot. Two brothers. It’s all that either of them have to prevent a sad and bloody ending, and for better or
worse…they’re both ready to take it. Partially AU, post-episodes 5.03 and 5.04…and not a one-shot despite the title!
On the Open Road by SilverMidnight52
Dean finds a letter from Sam when he was a teenager explaining why he killed himself.
Picking up the Pieces by DarkandtwistyGirl
A failed suicide attempt leaves Dean trying to pick up the shattered pieces of his family.
Residue by buffyaddict
Coda to episode 2x14, Born Under a Bad Sign. His whole life Dean has been there for him. Protected him. Shielded him. Saved him. But now Dean is the one who needs protection. Not from a ghost or a monster, from him. It's not about Dean saving Sam anymore. It's about Sam saving Dean.
Running Out of Time by authoressnebula
Gift for nyghtpet, post 2x02 ELAC: Dean won't speak, Sam won't ask anymore, but he feels like he needs to save Dean. In the end, though, it might be Dean who needs to save Sam.
Never Again by BroodyCheery323
After everything he had put Dean through, should he call him? Did he deserve to?
Silence to Regrets by stranded chess piece
Nothing is right. Sam thinks he has the fix, but Dean disagrees. Tag to 'Wishful Thinking.'
Sorrow Enough To Drown The World by chaosrosa (also here)
Sam is broken by all he has done. Dean shows up to try and save him. Will Sam let him?
The Blood in my Veins by DeppsLadyRosebud
Set before John's return for Dead Man's Blood, Salvation and Devils Trap. Sam's fears about the Demon's plans for him cause him to take drastic measures when he begins to contemplate who he really is… One Shot
The Letters to Silence by Desertfyre
Five times. Five times he has thought about it before he acted. The sixth time he couldn’t stand it. Silence followed. Maybe various letters would save him....before the silence wrapped him up forever.
There's a Gun In Your Hand (And It's Pointed At Your Head) by TheResurrectionist
Sam can't take it anymore. Can Dean? Written for the prompt, "I crawled out of hell once. Don't make me do it again."
This Life by TheRumor15
When Dean drops his amulet in the garbage can, something in Sam breaks.
To End aLife by dragongurl713
Six days spent thinking about the gun tucked in his waistband and what it would taste like.
Unanswered Calls by Onari
Alternative ending for Provenance. Sam's not answering Dean's call from the mausoleum...Brother's angst, nervous breakdown.
Until It's Gone by AlxM
Early Season 5 — AU — You never really know what you've got, until it's gone.
What I Can Do by HarvestMoonChild
AU: set between ELAC and Bloodlust. One Winchester decides to rewrite history to give his brother what he thinks he needs.
Wishing is Cold This Year by minviendha (also here and here)
“Strategically, it only makes sense, and I mean, I guess Dean might be a little upset, but he’d-” Sam swallowed, once, and Castiel saw a flicker of something, very briefly, before it was gone. “—he’d get over it.”.
For other flavors of suicidal!sam, or to leave comments, go to Suicidal!sam Compendium I Home
For suicidal!sam death!fic, go to Suicidal!sam Compendium II